Tag: self-abandonment

  • “Fitting in is the greatest barrier to belonging.”

    “Fitting in is the greatest barrier to belonging.”

    I heard Brené Brown say that on a podcast recently. I nearly skipped past it (she says a lot of things worth writing down), but this one stayed with me.

    It made me think about how often we confuse fitting in with being connected. In therapy, that confusion shows up all the time: people are exhausted from trying to be easy to like, easy to love, and easy to keep. I know that might sound calculated, but in these cases it’s more about survival. We learn early that approval feels safer than authenticity, and that lesson sticks.

    Hand holding one green apple among many red apples, an image of not fitting in and choosing to belong as yourself
    Belonging doesn’t require us to change who we are. It requires us to be who we are.

    It took me back to my younger self. The one who didn’t question much, who tried to move in step with everyone else. Back then, adulthood seemed to come with a ready-made script: go out, settle down, buy a house, have a baby, repeat. I thought that was just what being a functioning adult meant.

    It took a few detours to realise how much energy I’d spent trying to keep up. I wasn’t unhappy, exactly… just busy keeping pace. When life started to drift off-script, I expected disappointment. What I felt was relief.

    These days, I choose what fits me, not what looks good on paper. That still raises eyebrows sometimes, especially around the topic of children. People I’ve just met seem oddly invested in that decision. But I’ve stopped explaining. I’ve found people whose lives don’t need to mirror mine for us to feel close. That kind of belonging feels far less like a performance.

    The Psychology of Belonging

    In a landmark 1995 paper, the psychologists Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary argued that the need to belong is one of our most fundamental motivations, close to our need for food or safety. Rejection hurts, sometimes in a way that feels almost physical. Early brain-imaging studies suggested that social rejection and physical pain light up some of the same areas of the brain. Later research has found the picture is more complicated, and that the brain seems to process the two differently. But anyone who has been left out knows the ache is real. Which explains why we work so hard to fit in.

    But belonging isn’t about being included. It’s about being seen and recognised. Brené Brown puts the difference simply: fitting in is about becoming who you need to be in order to be accepted, while belonging doesn’t require us to change who we are.

    That distinction gets blurry early. We learn which parts of us are welcomed and which are inconvenient. So we start adjusting, smoothing our edges, editing our sentences. Those early edits don’t disappear; they just become habits. People-pleasing, overthinking, and constant self-checking are different flavours of the same survival strategy.

    I learnt to be easygoing, agreeable, and never too certain. It kept the peace, but I often felt like I was watching myself from a distance. There’s a loneliness in being well-liked for a version of yourself you barely recognise.

    Fitting in can feel like a slow fade, a series of small, polite disappearances.

    Fitting In as Self-Abandonment

    When I think of “fitting in” now, it feels like a slow fade, a series of small, polite disappearances. Saying yes when you mean no. Nodding through things you don’t believe in. Smiling instead of speaking up.

    Individually, none of those things looks serious. But over time, they pull you away from your own preferences until you can’t quite remember what they are.

    And it’s tiring. Research by Kathleen Vohs, Roy Baumeister and Natalie Ciarocco found that working hard to manage how others see us, especially in unfamiliar company, left people with less capacity for self-control afterwards. This area of research has been debated in recent years, and some of its findings haven’t held up well when repeated, so I’d hold it lightly. But it matches what many people describe: the mind calls it social intelligence; the body calls it exhaustion.

    I know that exhaustion. I blended in until I couldn’t hear my own thoughts. It wasn’t rebellion I feared (I am a proud rebel); it was isolation. But the irony is that the harder I tried to belong, the lonelier I became.

    Belonging to Ourselves First

    It took me a while to understand that belonging starts with yourself. Not with finding the right crowd, but with knowing your own values well enough to stay loyal to them.

    Research on self-compassion, the field Kristin Neff helped to build, offers an interesting angle on this. In one study, Joanna Arch and her colleagues gave women a few days of brief self-compassion practice before putting them through a stressful test in which they were judged by others. Compared with the control groups, they showed calmer physical stress responses and felt less anxious. It was a small study, but I like what it suggests: that being kind to ourselves may help settle the body’s response to feeling judged. Belonging as something we can partly offer ourselves, and not only a social achievement.

    For me, that looked like saying no when something feels wrong, even when it’s inconvenient. Choosing what feels right in my body, not just what looks sensible from the outside. Each time I practise this, life feels a little lighter, a little more honest.

    Living differently can look unusual from the outside. It can still be exactly where you’re meant to grow.

    When Belonging Looks Unusual

    Living in alignment can look odd from the outside. People notice when you don’t follow the usual route. My lack of maternal instinct, for example, continued to be headline material up to my early 40s. Apparently, I was expected to “change my mind” at some point, as though I’d misplaced it temporarily. (I didn’t.)

    I used to find those comments uncomfortable. Looking back now, I mostly find them funny. The confusion usually says more about the other person’s expectations than about me. Living differently can be unsettling for people who’ve never questioned the script. It hints that there might be more than one version of happy.

    I’ve stopped trying to make sense to everyone. The people who get it, who understand I’m not rejecting anything, just choosing differently, are the ones I keep close. Real belonging isn’t about matching. It’s about being met.

    Returning to Ourselves

    Hearing Brené Brown that day reminded me how long I spent trying to earn connection through conformity. I used to think I needed approval to feel safe. Now, when I notice myself editing again, I take it as a sign to pause.

    Life didn’t follow the neat timeline I once expected. I’m grateful for that. The detours brought me to a version of life that actually fits me. Not perfectly, but truthfully.

    The friendships I have now are easy in the best way: no performance, no persuasion.

    I still catch myself wondering sometimes if I seem “normal enough.” But the thought passes. Belonging isn’t about being understood by everyone. It’s about understanding yourself enough to stop chasing that.

    Questions to Sit With

    Where do I still adjust myself to stay accepted?

    What signals tell me I’ve stepped away from my own preferences?

    Who helps me feel at ease in my own company?


    If this resonates, you might also like How Belonging Shapes Our Thoughts and When Adaptation Becomes Self-Betrayal.

    If you’d like to explore this in therapy, I offer one-to-one sessions at Trueform Therapy, in person in Cardiff and online across the UK and EU. You’re welcome to get in touch for an initial conversation.


    If You Want to Explore These Ideas Further

    Brené Brown’s The Gifts of Imperfection (2010) and Braving the Wilderness (2017) both dig into the tension between fitting in and true belonging.

    Kristin Neff’s Self-Compassion: The Proven Power of Being Kind to Yourself (2011) offers a grounded, readable look at how kindness towards ourselves can change the way we respond to stress and self-criticism.

    For a more psychological angle, Roy Baumeister and Mark Leary’s classic paper, “The Need to Belong: Desire for Interpersonal Attachments as a Fundamental Human Motivation” (1995), set out why belonging matters so much to us.

    Each approaches belonging differently, but all point to the same idea: connection starts with how we relate to ourselves.

    And if you’d like to look at the research mentioned in this post:

    Arch and colleagues on self-compassion and stress responses: Greater Good Magazine

    Brené Brown on fitting in versus belonging: summary

    Woo and colleagues on how the brain processes rejection and physical pain (Nature Communications, 2014): summary