Tag: resistance

  • When Nothing Moves: What Being Stuck Might Be Protecting

    When Nothing Moves: What Being Stuck Might Be Protecting

    People often talk about being stuck as if it were a malfunction. As if something in them is failing to do its job.

    They know what needs to change. They’ve thought about it carefully. They may even be tired of talking about it.

    And yet, nothing shifts.

    Sitting with someone in that place, I’m rarely struck by a lack of effort. What I notice instead is how much pressure they are already under, usually from themselves.

    Two weathered blue boats with outboard engines sitting motionless on calm water at dusk, with misty hills in the distance, evoking the feeling of being stuck.
    Stillness isn’t always the absence of movement. Sometimes it’s a pause.

    When Different Needs Collide

    Stuckness tends to appear when different needs collide.

    On the one hand, there is usually a clear sense that something cannot continue as it is. A situation feels too heavy, too constricting, or too painful.

    On the other hand, change is not neutral. It asks for something in return. Sometimes what it asks for is obvious. Sometimes it isn’t. Either way, some part of us notices.

    Therapists from quite different traditions have arrived at a similar idea. In motivational interviewing, an approach developed by William Miller and Stephen Rollnick, feeling two ways about change is treated as a normal part of the process, not a sign that someone isn’t trying. The Harvard psychologists Robert Kegan and Lisa Lahey describe something they call an “immunity to change”: alongside the goal we want, we often hold a hidden competing commitment, such as staying liked, staying safe or staying the person others rely on. The two pull against each other, and the result looks like being stuck.

    What Change Can Cost

    One reason people get stuck is that change involves loss. Not always a dramatic one, but it’s always there.

    A familiar role might need to be loosened. A relationship might shift in ways that are hard to predict. A certain image of yourself (capable, agreeable, reliable) might no longer hold in the same way.

    When those losses come into view, slowing down can be a sensible response.

    Another reason is emotional exposure. Change often brings people closer to feelings they have organised their lives around not having to feel too much: grief, anger, fear, disappointment. If distance from those feelings has been protective in the past, hesitation makes sense. Pausing here can be a way of checking whether the ground is steady enough to finally make room for them.

    Why Knowing Isn’t Enough

    Then there is habit, though not in the superficial sense people usually mean.

    Ways of thinking about yourself, other people and the world tend to run on well-worn tracks. They take very little effort. New ways of responding take more energy, more attention and more tolerance for uncertainty. Knowing this doesn’t make the old tracks disappear.

    This is why insight alone rarely produces change. Most people already understand far more than they can easily live by.

    Research backs this up. When Thomas Webb and Paschal Sheeran reviewed dozens of studies in which people’s intentions were successfully changed, they found that their behaviour changed considerably less. Wanting to do something differently, even meaning it, is only part of the picture.

    Familiar patterns also have the advantage of being predictable. Predictable is not the same as comfortable, but it is often treated as safer. People routinely choose what they know how to manage over what might work better but feels less certain. They may complain about this choice at length while continuing to make it. That isn’t hypocrisy. It’s just human.

    Well-worn muddy footpath winding across a grassy hillside and disappearing into thick fog, with a fence line and wooded valley fading into the mist.
    The familiar path takes the least effort.

    More Than One Feeling

    Feeling stuck is not a single emotional state. It can include frustration, resignation, fear, numbness, or an odd flatness that doesn’t quite have a name. Sometimes these states take turns. Sometimes they sit alongside each other.

    None of this is particularly elegant. Psychological processes rarely are.

    Tightening the Screws

    What tends to complicate things further is pressure.

    When people decide they shouldn’t be stuck, they often respond by tightening the internal screws. More self-monitoring. More rules. Less patience.

    This is understandable, but it usually has the opposite effect. Something that is already cautious tends to become more so under threat.

    There’s some research that points the same way. In a series of studies, Juliana Breines and Serena Chen found that people who responded to a failure with self-compassion, rather than self-criticism, were more motivated to improve afterwards, not less. They studied longer for a retest and were more willing to make amends for a mistake. These were short experiments, mostly with students, so they’re a hint rather than proof. But they challenge the common belief that being hard on ourselves is what gets us moving.

    What Feeling Stuck Might Be Doing

    Seen this way, stuckness is often doing something.

    It may be buying time. It may be preventing a loss that feels too large. It may be holding the line until something feels possible rather than merely necessary.

    This doesn’t mean staying where you are indefinitely. It means recognising that being stuck can have a function before trying to dismantle it.

    From the outside, being stuck can look like nothing is happening. From the inside, there is often a careful, if uncomfortable, negotiation going on. When that negotiation is understood rather than overridden, movement, when it comes, tends to be slower and steadier.

    Sometimes nothing moves because something important is being held in place.

    The outer leaves of a bud protect it until it’s ready to open.

    If this resonates, you might also like Why Trying to Calm Down Can Keep You Anxious and When Psychological Frameworks Help Us Understand Ourselves.

    Therapy can be a place to slow down and understand what being stuck might be protecting, without adding more pressure. At Trueform Therapy, I offer one-to-one sessions in person in Cardiff and online across the UK and EU. You’re welcome to get in touch to ask any questions before booking.


    If You Want to Explore These Ideas Further

    Robert Kegan and Lisa Lahey’s Immunity to Change (2009) was written with workplaces in mind, but its central idea, that we’re often committed to not changing for good reasons we haven’t noticed, applies far more widely.

    William Miller and Stephen Rollnick’s Motivational Interviewing (third edition, 2013) is written for practitioners, but its chapters on ambivalence are a thoughtful read for anyone who has ever felt two ways about something.

    Kristin Neff’s Self-Compassion (2011) explores why kindness towards ourselves can be more motivating than pressure.

    And if you’d like to look at the research directly: